Best Paths

Demonstration 2

HVDC-VSC multivendor interoperability: three makers on one DC grid

Every HVDC link in Europe used to come from a single supplier. The second BEST PATHS demonstration put rival converter controls on the same test bench to see whether that could change.

On this page
  1. Who took part
  2. Why converters from different vendors clash
  3. How the tests were run
  4. What the demonstration found
  5. Where interoperability stands now

In a laboratory run by the French grid operator RTE, control cubicles from different HVDC manufacturers had been wired into the same real-time simulation, something never done before, and in June 2018 visitors watched live what happened when they were asked to run one DC grid together. They did not simply cooperate. That result, obtained within the second BEST PATHS demonstration, was the point of four years of work: until then no one had shown systematically where converters from rival suppliers clash, or how to fix it.

The reason it mattered is structural. Europe’s HVDC links based on voltage source converters (VSC) had never had interoperability problems, because each link had been bought from a single supplier, both ends and the control system included. Multi-terminal links and meshed DC grids break that model. A network built in stages, over years, will almost certainly end up with converters from more than one manufacturer.

Who took part

RTE led the demonstration. Three leading HVDC manufacturers took part (ABB, Alstom Grid and Siemens), together with the system operators Elia of Belgium and Red Eléctrica de España, and two universities, Centrale Lille and the University of Strathclyde. The mix was deliberate: manufacturers who normally compete, operators who would have to buy the equipment, and academics with no product to defend.

Why converters from different vendors clash

A modular multilevel converter, the VSC design used in current HVDC projects, is mostly hardware that any maker could build. What distinguishes one vendor’s converter from another’s is the control and protection software that decides how it reacts to every change on the grid. Olivier Despouys, the RTE engineer who managed the work, made the point in a 2018 interview: the hardware is not the key element, the algorithms are, and they are patented and closely guarded.

That creates a trap. Solving an interoperability problem between two converters seems to require each vendor to see the other’s algorithms, which neither will allow. Even sharing measurement data is sensitive, because a competitor could work backwards from the outputs. Despouys also dismissed the idea of agreeing on one common technology, since HVDC converters were changing so fast that today’s shared design would not stay shared for long.

China had already built multi-vendor systems, at Nan’ao and Zhoushan. Despouys’s view was that those projects could not be copied in Europe: in both, one manufacturer was put in charge of control and protection for every converter, whoever built it. In a competitive European market that arrangement is not expected to be the way forward.

His proposed way out was a neutral third party that tests the vendors’ models or control replicas, identifies where they conflict and suggests changes to each vendor separately, so that competitors never deal with each other directly. Demo 2 was, in effect, a trial of that method with RTE in the middle.

How the tests were run

The demonstration moved in stages. First, the partners defined a set of DC system topologies covering a wide range of situations: connections to strong and weak AC networks, to offshore wind farms, converters close to each other electrically and converters attached to separate AC grids. They then wrote functional specifications describing how an AC/DC converter should behave in normal operation, during and after a fault, and during special sequences such as start-up, connection, disconnection and shutdown.

Next, the manufacturers adapted their converter models and controls to meet those specifications and supplied them for offline simulation in the electromagnetic transient software EMTP-RV. The models were combined in multi-vendor configurations on the agreed topologies. Problems were expected to appear at this stage in three places: at the interface between two vendors’ equipment, between an external master control and the converters, or wherever the specifications proved too loose for a multi-vendor project.

The offline results produced a first set of recommendations and a more detailed specification for control replicas. The replicas were physical cubicles: exact hardware copies of each manufacturer’s control system as it would be installed in a real HVDC project. RTE then connected them to its real-time simulator and ran them on the same topologies. A separate check, run with the first demonstration, compared the three vendors’ “black box” converter models with an open academic model to see how closely a public model could stand in for the proprietary ones.

What the demonstration found

The findings were presented to manufacturers at a workshop in Paris on 5 June 2018. According to RTE, the investigation not only confirmed that interoperability problems exist between the main vendors’ current technology but also solved some of them. Converters, in Despouys’s phrase, are not “plug’n’play”: they cannot simply replace one another, and technical adaptations are needed first. The project’s closing statement added a detail with practical weight: some of the issues could be fixed by one vendor adjusting its control strategy, without the others changing anything.

The written output came in two rounds. A first set of recommendations for standardisation bodies, system operators, vendors and researchers was published in October 2016. The final recommendations for interoperability of multi-terminal, multi-vendor HVDC networks followed at the end of the project, and in November 2018 the team presented its results at a joint workshop with CENELEC TC8X/WG 06, the European working group on system aspects of HVDC grids. The recommendations were also meant to feed the drafting teams of ENTSO-E’s network codes and international standards work at CENELEC and the IEC.

The three benefits the partners set out at the start were modest and specific: a better understanding of how VSC-HVDC converters behave and should be controlled in future DC grids, a real step towards standardised converters thanks to the three manufacturers taking part, and the removal of one of the last technical barriers to large amounts of renewable power, offshore wind included.

Where interoperability stands now

Multi-terminal HVDC has since arrived in Europe. The Shetland link and the Caithness–Moray link in Scotland now operate as one multi-terminal VSC system, and TenneT’s 2 GW offshore platforms are designed to be ready for multi-terminal operation. The question BEST PATHS raised has become a project in its own right: InterOPERA, funded under Horizon Europe from January 2023 to April 2027, brings HVDC vendors, system operators and wind companies together to make future HVDC systems interoperable by design.

That continuity is the fairest measure of Demo 2. It did not make converters interchangeable, and no one expected it to. It showed that the problem was real, that it could be tested without anyone handing over their algorithms, and that part of it could be fixed. The first demonstration’s offshore wind laboratory attacked the same interactions from the other side, with open models in place of vendor hardware; the HVDC explainer covers the converter types themselves. Whether the first genuinely mixed-vendor meshed grid in European waters will follow RTE’s third-party method is a decision that belongs to the operators ordering the next platforms.

From the project record

  1. News · Interview

    Bidding on renewables: an interview with the Best Paths coordinator

    Vicente González López of Red Eléctrica on integrating large-scale renewables, VSC converter interoperability, security of supply and the cost to consumers.

  2. Event ·

    Demo 2 Special Workshop: multivendor interoperability in HVDC systems

    The Demo 2 special workshop in Paris on 5 June 2018, where RTE showed HVDC control cubicles from different vendors running on one real-time simulator.

  3. News ·

    Direct current grids: interoperability is key to their development

    May 2018: RTE researcher Olivier Despouys on why HVDC converters from different vendors are not plug and play, and how a third party could close the gap.

  4. News ·

    Creating Europe's new backbone for efficient power distribution

    July 2017: why a pan-European grid would rest on HVDC lines and voltage source converters, with Red Eléctrica's González López and Strathclyde's Finney.

Questions

What does interoperability mean for HVDC converters?

It means that converters from different manufacturers can be connected to the same DC system and operate together without upsetting each other, in normal running, during faults and in sequences such as start-up and shutdown. Because each vendor's control and protection software is proprietary, two converters that work perfectly on their own can still behave badly once they share one network.

Which companies took part in BEST PATHS Demo 2?

The French system operator RTE led it. The manufacturers were ABB, Alstom Grid and Siemens, the operators Elia and Red Eléctrica de España joined as future buyers of the equipment, and Centrale Lille and the University of Strathclyde contributed the academic side. RTE's laboratory hosted the real-time tests with the vendors' control cubicles.

Did Demo 2 find real interoperability problems?

Yes. RTE reported in June 2018 that the tests confirmed the existence of interoperability issues between the main vendors' current technology and also solved some of them. The project's closing statement noted that certain issues could be removed by one vendor changing its control strategy, while the others left theirs untouched.

Why were the Chinese multi-vendor HVDC projects not a model for Europe?

In the Nan'ao and Zhoushan schemes, a single manufacturer handled control and protection for every converter, including those made by other suppliers. RTE's Olivier Despouys argued that such an arrangement does not fit a competitive European market, where vendors guard their control algorithms and no operator wants one firm in charge of a whole DC grid.

Follow the line

  1. Demonstration 1 HVDC offshore wind links: how a far-offshore wind farm gets its grid connection

    How HVDC offshore wind links bring power ashore from distant farms, why their converters interact, and what the Demo 1 lab in Trondheim tested.

  2. Direct current HVDC transmission explained: the cable, the converter station and why DC wins

    How HVDC transmission works: why DC wins on long and subsea routes, LCC vs VSC, what sits inside a converter station and which cable types run in Europe.

  3. Demonstration 3 Upgrading multi-terminal HVDC links: the SACOI line as a test bed

    How BEST PATHS Demo 3 used SACOI, the Sardinia–Corsica–Italy link, to test converters, deep-water cables, DC conductors and insulators for HVDC.

  4. Publications BEST PATHS publications: reports, deliverables and press releases

    The BEST PATHS publications of 2015–2018 in date order: deliverables on HVDC, interoperability and superconducting links, event reports and press releases.