News · May 2018
Direct current grids: interoperability is key to their development
Converters from different suppliers often fail to communicate well with one another, a problem for the electricity highways of the future. RTE's Olivier Despouys explained why.
On this page
Calling a friend on a different mobile network, or taking cash from another bank’s machine, works because of interoperability: the ability of two or more networks, systems, devices, applications or components to exchange information. In an electric power system the term means end-to-end connectivity between different equipment, from generation all the way to the customer.
Direct current is expected to take over from alternating current in parts of the grid. It is the preferred way of moving large amounts of power over long distances, with higher overall efficiency and reliability than an AC system of the same size, as Clean Line Energy’s HVDC overview put it.
The new DC grids will rely on controls, computers, automation and new equipment working together. Interoperability is one of the hardest problems, because many technologies, systems and devices must communicate with each other securely and reliably.
The state of play in Europe was put to Olivier Despouys, R&D researcher at RTE (Réseau de transport d’électricité) in Paris. The subject was also the theme of the BEST PATHS special workshop “Maximising multivendor interoperability in HVDC systems”, held in Paris on 5 June 2018.
Where Europe stood
Until then, Despouys said, Europe’s HVDC links had had no interoperability problems, because each was built by a single supplier. Future DC systems were expected to involve several converter suppliers using different technologies, and that would create new problems.
Did a technical solution exist? Recent results from Demonstration 2 of BEST PATHS showed that the technology supplied by the main HVDC vendors was not directly interoperable. Converters were not “plug and play” and could not be swapped for one another: some technical adaptation was needed first.
The Chinese precedent
Chinese manufacturers had delivered interoperable converters in two recent projects, Nan’Ao and Zhoushan. According to Despouys, that could not be carried over to Europe or other western countries because of the competitive setting. In both Chinese projects one manufacturer was responsible for the control and protection of every converter, including those supplied by others, and that single implementation was what made the components fit together smoothly. In western countries, where HVDC is a competitive market, that arrangement was not the expected way forward.
One supplier, or one technology?
In the short term, he said, some planned European HVDC projects were likely to be extended in stages: a first link built with one converter supplier at both ends, then a supplier, possibly a different one, chosen for the extension.
“The provision of a converter by a unique manufacturer is not a valid option in the long term as we are thinking of pan-European DC grids (also referred to as ‘electric highways’ or ‘supergrids’); therefore, a single supplier could be considered for a limited number of converters, but could not be responsible for the provision of all converters in such a massive infrastructure.”
Getting all manufacturers onto the same technology was equally impossible, in his view. HVDC technology was still changing fast, and what was in use then differed greatly from what had been used only a couple of years earlier. Even if every supplier agreed on a common technology, nothing guaranteed it would stay interoperable.
So manufacturers needed to focus on designs and requirements expected to reduce interoperability problems, if not remove them, which was what the BEST PATHS researchers were doing in Demonstration 2, and to move towards standardised products. “This is really a key factor!” he said.
Competition and patents
Before any technical question comes a commercial one. Every vendor needs to protect its knowledge of the detailed control and protection inside its converters. The hardware is not the core asset; the algorithms that govern a converter’s behaviour are, and they are patented to keep competitors from using similar techniques.
Solving interoperability by having vendors share those algorithms was therefore out of the question. Even exchanging data or measurements was sensitive, since it could allow reverse engineering, meaning an attempt to work out a competitor’s algorithms and parameters from their outputs.
A possible way out
With no legal solution available at the time, Despouys suggested bringing in a third party. Using control replicas or models supplied by the manufacturers, it could identify interoperability problems and propose adaptations to each vendor, so that competitors would never deal with each other directly.
Demonstration 2 itself ran its simulations with converter models from ABB, Alstom and Siemens; how that work was set up is described on the Demonstration 2 page.