Demonstration 3
Upgrading multi-terminal HVDC links: the SACOI line as a test bed
The oldest multi-terminal HVDC system in the world was due for replacement. The third BEST PATHS demonstration used it to test the parts a successor could be built from.
On this page
The substation at Codrongianos, in the north of Sardinia, is where the island’s direct-current link to the Italian mainland begins. The link, known as SACOI, also stops on the way in Corsica, at Lucciana, which made it, in Terna’s words, the first multi-terminal HVDC system in the world. By the time BEST PATHS started in 2014 it was nearing the end of a record working life and due for replacement. The third demonstration of the project, led by the Italian system operator Terna, used SACOI as its laboratory: a real, three-terminal HVDC line on which to design and test the components that a modern replacement would need.
Why SACOI made a good test case
Few HVDC systems contain as many different parts. According to Terna, SACOI has three converter stations, overhead lines, land and submarine cables, sea electrodes, and power that can flow in any direction between the three ends. The site’s record of the SACOI link gives its route as 385 km, of which 121 km is subsea, with 264 km of overhead line. Its first stage, using mercury-arc valves, dates from 1967–68; a second stage with thyristor valves and 300 MW followed in 1992.
Multi-terminal operation is what sets SACOI apart. On a point-to-point link one converter sends and the other receives, and the control problem is contained. With a third station in the middle, power can enter or leave at any of three points, and each converter has to keep the DC voltage stable while the others change their flows. A fault on one section must be isolated without collapsing the whole system. Those are the same problems a future meshed DC grid will face, only on a smaller scale, and SACOI had been living with them for decades.
That mix is what made it useful. A component tested on SACOI has to work alongside everything an HVDC system can contain, on a link that secures supply for two islands. Terna also saw a practical challenge in the rehabilitation itself: rebuilding an existing line inside today’s regulatory and territorial limits is harder than it sounds.
The components tested
The work combined numerical simulation with the design and manufacture of prototypes and full-scale components, some intended for installation on a minor section of the SACOI link. The partners were Terna Rete Italia, the Italian research centre RSE, Toshiba T&D Europe, Nexans and the insulator maker De Angeli Prodotti.
The work covered five areas:
- Converters. A multilevel voltage source converter was taken from concept through design and manufacture to testing, with advanced control functions. One open question was whether VSC technology suits an unbalanced bipolar HVDC link that falls back on ground return in an emergency.
- Fault management and cables. DC fault management on cable systems, and submarine and land cables with extruded insulation. At the time 320 kV was the practical limit for extruded DC cable; the aim was to go higher, for submarine routes down to 450 m depth.
- Overhead conductors. High-temperature low-sag (HTLS) conductors adapted for DC, in versions with Kevlar and with carbon fibre.
- Insulators. Cap and pin insulators pre-coated with room-temperature vulcanised (RTV) silicone rubber, designed for DC lines.
- Fault location. Better analysis of where a cable fault lies, to shorten the outage while it is repaired.
The fault-location item deserves a note. A submarine cable fault is found by sending signals along the cable and reading the reflections, and every kilometre of uncertainty means more time at sea for the repair vessel. On a link that is the only DC connection for two islands, shortening that search shortens the time both are without it.
Around those parts sat a system study: the design, performance and techno-economic analysis of rehabilitating a three-terminal HVDC link, with control strategies for multi-terminal operation and a cost-benefit analysis of revamping the existing Italian line completely.
What the demonstration reported
The results were presented at a workshop held at the Codrongianos substation on 9 May 2018. The partners reported an industrial-size converter prototype built and tested; improved extruded submarine and land cables for very high voltage and depth, investigated up to qualification tests; and first-of-a-kind HVDC conductors and new insulators for overhead lines, successfully tested in field application. The visit that followed took in the substation’s HVDC equipment, its synchronous condensers and a storage laboratory with large electrochemical batteries.
Antonio Iliceto of Terna, who chaired the BEST PATHS consortium, argued that the full range of components could be used to rehabilitate other existing interconnections as well as to build new ones. He credited the result to the way the demonstration was organised, as a collaboration between public and private parties that made the results immediately replicable. That is a claim the record supports only in part: the parts were tested and qualified, but a qualification test is not years of service at sea.
Cable engineering is where the payoff is easiest to see. Extruded insulation above 320 kV, deep enough for Mediterranean crossings, is the kind of step that decides which sea routes are affordable. The site’s guide to subsea power cables explains why depth and voltage set the price of a crossing.
SACOI 3: the replacement now being built
The successor, SACOI 3, is under construction. According to the site’s SACOI 3 record, it will be a ±200 kV bipole of 400 MW, with converters from Hitachi Energy and subsea cables from Prysmian: about 105 km between Suvereto in Tuscany and Lucciana, and 16 km between Lucciana and Codrongianos. Onshore works began in 2025 and operation is forecast for 2029.
One detail stands out. Neither of the two main suppliers named for SACOI 3 was among the Demo 3 industrial partners, so the prototypes tested at Codrongianos are not, on the public record, the equipment going into the new link. What carries over is the knowledge: the system studies, the fault-location work and the evidence about what a three-terminal VSC scheme on this route requires. Readers interested in why a multi-terminal link with converters from more than one supplier is hard to run can follow the problem in Demo 2, and the HVDC explainer covers the converter technologies.
Whether the Corsican tap at Lucciana will run as a full third terminal of a VSC system, the arrangement Demo 3 studied, is something only SACOI 3’s commissioning, forecast for 2029, will show.
From the project record
-
Event ·
Demo 3 Special Workshop: Upgrading multiterminal HVDC interconnectors
The Demo 3 special workshop at Terna's Codrongianos substation in Sardinia on 9 May 2018, on new HVDC components tested for the SACOI link.
-
News ·
Demo 3 Special Workshop: upgrading multi-terminal HVDC interconnectors
April 2018: Terna announced the third BEST PATHS special workshop on upgrading the SACOI link, with a visit to its Codrongianos station in Sardinia.
-
News ·
Undersea HVDC cables: some of the world's top power interconnections
July 2017: SAPEI, SACOI, NorNed, NordBalt, BritNed, Baltic Cable and Skagerrak, six subsea power links between regions and countries and how they were built.
Questions
What is the SACOI link?
SACOI is the direct-current connection between Sardinia, Corsica and mainland Italy, running from Codrongianos in Sardinia to Suvereto in Tuscany with an intermediate station at Lucciana in Corsica. Its route is about 385 km long, 121 km of it under the sea. Terna describes it as the first multi-terminal HVDC system in the world.
Who carried out BEST PATHS Demo 3?
The Italian transmission system operator Terna Rete Italia led the demonstration. Its partners were the research centre RSE and three manufacturers: Toshiba T&D Europe, the cable maker Nexans and the insulator producer De Angeli Prodotti. The final results were shown at Terna's Codrongianos substation in Sardinia on 9 May 2018.
Which components did Demo 3 develop and test?
Five groups of parts: a multilevel voltage source converter prototype with advanced controls, extruded submarine and land cables aimed above the 320 kV limit of the time, high-temperature low-sag conductors for DC overhead lines in Kevlar and carbon-fibre versions, RTV-coated cap and pin insulators for DC, and improved methods for locating cable faults.
Is SACOI being replaced?
Yes. The successor, SACOI 3, is under construction as a ±200 kV bipole of 400 MW. Hitachi Energy is supplying the converters and Prysmian the subsea cables, about 105 km from Suvereto to Lucciana and 16 km from Lucciana to Codrongianos. Onshore works started in 2025, and operation is forecast for 2029.