Best Paths

Demonstration 4

Repowering transmission lines: reconductoring and dynamic line rating on Europe's AC grid

New overhead lines in Europe face long planning and local opposition. The fourth BEST PATHS demonstration looked for more capacity in the lines that already stand: hotter conductors, dynamic line rating, slimmer towers and repairs done under voltage.

Line drawing of lattice pylons crossing a ploughed field, the conductors sagging towards a row of trees, one wire drawn darker than the rest

Load the line

One span of an overhead power line Two lattice towers carry a conductor 350 metres across open country above a line of trees. As current rises the conductor heats, lengthens and sags closer to the trees.
Load
600A
Conductor
42°C
Sag at mid-span
9.1m
Clearance to trees
6.9m / min 5.0

Clearance held

Use the slider or drag the wire down. Shown at 600 A. More current heats the conductor; hot metal expands, and the longer wire hangs lower until the gap to the trees is gone. That gap, not the metal itself, usually sets how much a line may carry. A high-temperature, low-sag conductor expands far less, so the same towers can take more load.

A 350 m span with 8 m of sag at 20 °C. Figures are illustrative and the vertical scale is exaggerated.
On this page
  1. Why a line’s rating is lower than its metal allows
  2. Dynamic line rating with low-cost sensors
  3. Reconductoring with high-temperature low-sag conductors
  4. Voltage uprating: insulated cross-arms and a composite tower
  5. Repowering transmission lines while they stay live
  6. The line upgrading package
  7. What still limits repowering transmission lines

Between the 1960s and the 1990s, building new high-voltage overhead lines was routine work for European grid operators. By 2018 it was not. Matthias Müller-Mienack, head of research and studies at GridLab and chairman of the fourth BEST PATHS demonstration, described the change at a workshop in Budapest that April: people object more loudly to new pylons, and even maintenance on existing lines has to be planned years ahead, because the network is so heavily loaded that no one wants to switch off a critical line for long. The response is repowering transmission lines that already exist, with tools such as reconductoring and dynamic line rating, and Demo 4 was the part of BEST PATHS (2014–2018) that tested how.

The demonstration was led by the German system operator 50Hertz. It split its work into three parallel strands. The first researched high-temperature low-sag (HTLS) conductors, with a focus on how they age, and the benefits of insulated cross-arms. The second tested new line designs and field methods, including retrofitting and live-line working. The third built a prototype dynamic line rating system from low-cost sensors, so that existing conductors could safely run hotter. Put together, those strands cover most of the ways to get more power through a corridor that is already there.

Why a line’s rating is lower than its metal allows

A power line is limited by heat long before the metal is in danger. Current warms the conductor, the conductor expands, and a longer wire between two fixed towers hangs lower. Every span has a lowest point that must stay a safe distance above ground, roads, buildings and trees. Once the hottest permitted wire would breach that clearance, the line is full.

How hot the wire gets depends on the weather as much as on the load. Wind carries heat away; sun and still, warm air trap it. Operators traditionally set a fixed seasonal rating for each line, computed for unfavourable conditions, so that the limit holds on the worst afternoon of the year. Most of the time the line could safely carry more.

There are two broad ways out. One is to know the real conditions and use the headroom they give, which is dynamic line rating. The other is to change the hardware so that heat matters less: a conductor that sags less when hot, which is the usual meaning of reconductoring, or a higher voltage on the same route, which carries more power for the same current. Demo 4 worked on both routes to repowering transmission lines.

For scale, the International Energy Agency now gives these ranges: dynamic line rating adds 20–30% of capacity in one to two years, reconductoring 50–100% in three to four years, and voltage uprating 100–200% in four to seven years. The IEA counts such measures among the ways to connect 450–700 GW of projects stuck in grid connection queues worldwide.

Dynamic line rating with low-cost sensors

The DLR strand had three goals: a new type of dynamic line rating implementation, more efficient use of existing conductors, and conductor monitoring through a new sensor and its software. The emphasis on low cost was deliberate: a rating system only pays for itself if it covers the spans that actually limit the line, and that means many sensors.

In practice a dynamic line rating system estimates, span by span, how hot the conductor is and how far it has sagged. Some systems measure the weather at the line and calculate the conductor temperature from it; others measure the conductor itself, its temperature, tension or clearance. Either way, the result is a rating that moves with the conditions, updated often enough for the control room to use it. The weak point is coverage: the line is only as strong as its worst span, and a sensor on a sheltered span can overestimate what an exposed one can take.

Vanessa Gombert, project manager at 50Hertz, tied the work to forecasting. A line near a wind cluster carries most power when the wind blows, which is also when the wind cools the wire. Good weather forecasts let an operator plan the feed-in, and a cheap sensor on the line confirms the conditions as they happen, so the line can be run safely at a higher load. In April 2018 the project reported a prototype sensor that allows lines to operate at higher capacity in real time.

Measuring ratings well also means comparing methods. At the ICOLIM conference in Strasbourg in April 2017, the Swedish testing firm STRI presented a comparison of two thermal rating methods, I-line and the one set out in Cigré Technical Brochure 601. The detail matters more than it seems: two correct calculations of the same span can give different limits, and the gap is capacity either lost or overdrawn.

Reconductoring with high-temperature low-sag conductors

A conventional overhead conductor is aluminium strands around a steel core (ACSR). HTLS conductors replace the core or the alloy with materials that expand less as they heat, so the wire can carry more current before it sags to the clearance limit. Reconductoring with HTLS lets an operator raise a line’s capacity on the existing towers.

The difficulty in 2014 was experience. European system operators had little long-term data on how the newer conductors age. Demo 4’s partners, among them the Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM), TU Dresden and 50Hertz, ran new long-term mechanical and electrical tests on HTLS wires, looking at temperature, electrical and mechanical effects, creep and fatigue. The testing scheme allowed, for the first time, a direct and comprehensive comparison of different HTLS wire types. The results fed improved line models for capacity and sag.

One of the pilot options the demonstration described was simpler still: replacing a single conductor per phase with a bundle of two, “simplex to duplex”, in the same corridor and with as few outages as possible.

Voltage uprating: insulated cross-arms and a composite tower

The second hardware route is a higher voltage within the same corridor. An insulated cross-arm, made of composite insulators, lets the wires be fixed directly to the tower instead of hanging from long insulator strings. That shortens the tower, narrows the corridor and reduces how far the wires swing in the wind. The same technique can raise the voltage of an existing line.

The Belgian operator Elia designed and installed insulated cross-arms for a new overhead line, and the erection and operating procedures were tested on the STEVIN project, a 47 km, 380 kV link between Zeebrugge and Zomergem built to bring offshore wind power inland. Because no standards existed for insulated cross-arms, the partners also wrote new test methods for their long-term electrical performance, including water-induced corona, pollution, tracking and erosion tests running 5,000 hours. A paper by STRI and Elia on the first pollution and corona results was accepted for the Cigré SC D1 Colloquium in 2015 and proposed a new test procedure for composite insulators.

The cross-arm tests were detailed enough to shape practice beyond the project. Pollution testing used the Rapid Flashover Method on composite insulators, following the principles of Cigré Technical Brochure 555, across seven operating positions and several levels of pollution severity; the results gave correction factors for position, for the number of parallel insulators and for the recovery of the surface’s water-repellent properties. The corona work produced a new Water Drop Corona Induced test, checked on three composite insulators of very different design and put forward as an extra type test for utilities to write into their purchase specifications. In a related paper, ABB and STRI presented a method for dimensioning the grading rings on composite insulators so as to reduce damage from water, one of the main causes of ageing on transmission lines.

The third design was a composite tower for 420 kV lines, much lighter than a steel lattice tower and less visible. Its low weight cut the number of helicopter lifts needed during construction by at least 50%, and larger parts with fewer joints made it quicker to assemble.

Repowering transmission lines while they stay live

Every upgrade means work on the line, and every outage is a cost. The live-line working strand looked at doing the work under voltage, which requires handling the electric and magnetic fields around the conductor, moving a conductor car along the wires past insulators, and replacing glass and composite insulator strings.

The best-known result came from the Budapest High Voltage Laboratory at BME. Its new extra-light conductor car for live-line working won both the Best Paper and the Best Innovation awards at ICOLIM 2017. The partners also developed a new insulated mounting chair and a technique for installing aircraft warning markers by robot. At the Budapest workshop on 5 April 2018, organised by the Hungarian operator MAVIR and BME with 50Hertz, participants watched a damper exchange and an insulator replacement carried out under voltage in BME’s high-voltage laboratory.

The line upgrading package

The demonstration’s output was a self-standing package for system operators, meant to make overhead lines more compact (and so easier to accept visually and lighter on rights of way), better able to cope with fluctuating power flows, more flexible in operation, and affordable to build and maintain. It was framed as a way of repowering transmission lines that other ENTSO-E members could repeat without starting over.

The partners named for Demo 4 were 50Hertz (leader), Elia, Statnett, MAVIR, STRI, EFLA, BME VIKING, BAM and TU Dresden; the April 2018 workshop also credited Red Eléctrica de España and Relogable.

What still limits repowering transmission lines

Repowering transmission lines is cheaper than building new ones, and the gap is wide: Müller-Mienack put the investment for extra-high-voltage underground XLPE cable at typically five to ten times that of an overhead line of the same capacity. The underground alternative has limits of its own, which he also listed. Onshore, XLPE cable can only be delivered in lengths of up to 1,150 metres per phase conductor, so joint bays have to be built every 700 to 1,000 metres. Trenches collide with water pipes, gas lines and sewers, and heavy machinery needs access roads. Repairs take longer: citing a Cigré report covering 2000 to 2005, he noted that more than a third of extra-high-voltage cable faults were repaired within a week and more than 75% within a month, which leaves up to a quarter taking longer. That makes a stronger existing line the first option almost everywhere. You would expect every operator to use it at once. They do not, for three reasons the demonstration’s own work points to.

The first is trust in materials. A new conductor or cross-arm must last decades, and without standards each operator has to run its own tests. The second is operations: a dynamic rating is only useful if control rooms and market rules let the extra capacity be used. The third is scale. A handful of sensors on a few spans proves the method; covering a network is a procurement decision.

The IEA’s current numbers suggest the gains Demo 4 went after are real and large. What the project could not settle was how long regulators and system operators would take to treat a line’s rating as something that changes with the weather. The site’s guide to grid congestion follows that question through to today’s connection queues, and the glossary defines the line terms used here. For the DC side of the same problem, Demo 3 developed HTLS conductors for HVDC overhead lines.

From the project record

  1. News ·

    Repowering extra-high voltage lines: new technologies seen in Budapest

    April 2018: MAVIR, BME and 50Hertz presented insulated cross-arms, HTLS conductors, a 420 kV composite tower and dynamic line rating.

  2. Event ·

    Demo 4 Special Workshop: Innovative repowering of AC corridors

    Budapest, 5 April 2018: insulated cross-arms, HTLS conductors, a composite tower and live-line working, shown under voltage.

  3. News ·

    "Compacting" electricity lines

    March 2018: GridLab's Matthias Müller-Mienack on insulated cross-arms, the Belgian Stevin line and the costs and repair times of underground XLPE cables.

  4. Event ·

    19th International Symposium on High Voltage Engineering (ISH 2015)

    The 19th International Symposium on High Voltage Engineering in Pilsen, August 2015, and the two insulated cross-arm papers the project presented there.

Questions

What does repowering transmission lines mean?

It means raising the amount of power an existing overhead line can carry without building a new route. The usual methods are reconductoring (fitting a conductor that can run hotter or carry more current), dynamic line rating (setting the limit from measured weather instead of fixed assumptions), and voltage uprating, for example with insulated cross-arms that allow a higher voltage on the same corridor.

How much extra capacity does dynamic line rating give?

The International Energy Agency puts the gain from dynamic line rating at 20–30% of a line's capacity, with an implementation time of one to two years. The gain is not constant: it is largest when wind cools the conductor and smallest on hot, still days, which are the conditions a fixed rating assumes all year.

What is reconductoring and how much does it add?

Reconductoring replaces the wires on existing towers with a conductor that can carry more current, often a high-temperature low-sag (HTLS) type that stays tight even when hot. The IEA estimates a capacity gain of 50–100%, over three to four years. The towers usually stay, which avoids a new planning process for the route.

Why does a hot power line sag?

Current heats the conductor, and metal expands as it warms. A longer wire between two fixed towers hangs lower. The lowest point of the span must stay a safe distance above the ground, trees and roads, so that clearance, and not the metal itself, often sets the line's limit. HTLS conductors are built to expand less.

What did BEST PATHS Demo 4 deliver?

A package for grid operators combining tested HTLS conductors, insulated cross-arms installed on a new Belgian line, a lighter composite tower design for 420 kV, a low-cost sensor prototype for dynamic line rating, and new live-line working tools, including an extra-light conductor car that won the Best Innovation award at ICOLIM 2017.

Follow the line

  1. Guide Grid congestion: why Europe pays billions to move power it already has

    What grid congestion is, what redispatch and curtailment cost in Germany and the EU, why Dutch firms wait for connections, and which fixes work.

  2. Demonstration 3 Upgrading multi-terminal HVDC links: the SACOI line as a test bed

    How BEST PATHS Demo 3 used SACOI, the Sardinia–Corsica–Italy link, to test converters, deep-water cables, DC conductors and insulators for HVDC.

  3. Demonstration 5 An MgB2 superconducting cable for gigawatt power transmission

    The BEST PATHS MgB2 superconducting cable: a 320 kV, 10 kA DC loop for 3.2 GW of power transmission, what it proved and what still holds it back.

  4. Glossary Power grid glossary: the terms behind HVDC and interconnectors

    Plain-English definitions of the terms used on Europe's power grid, from ampacity and bidding zone to VSC, XLPE and extra high voltage transmission.