News · July 2018
Baltic energy systems: synchronising with continental Europe by 2025
Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia joined the European Union in 2004, yet their grids still ran in step with Russia and Belarus. In 2018 they set a date to change that.
On this page
At the end of June 2018 the three Baltic states and Poland reached a political agreement on synchronising the Baltic States’ electricity grid with the continental European network by 2025.
A grid built for the Soviet Union
The power systems of Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia were historically part of the Soviet “unified energy system”. When the USSR broke up in 1992, the technical problem of separating them arose. At the time a range of factors, among them limited alternatives and the high reliability of the Soviet network, argued for keeping the systems joined.
In 2001 the existing synchronous operation with Russia and Belarus was written into the BRELL agreement, which dealt with the technical side of power exchange. “It was a technical agreement signed at a time when no other conditions were available,” said Dangiras Mikalajunas, former chief executive of the Lithuanian energy company Lietuvos Energija.
In 2018 the Baltic power systems were still tightly tied to the Russian and Belarusian systems through 330 kV AC lines. They imported electricity generated in Russia, drew on the other countries’ power reserves and took part in joint dispatch and regulation.
All three countries had long regarded this dependence on Moscow as a threat, and the crisis in Ukraine sharpened the concern. Cutting the cord proved hard.
Building the links west
In the early 2000s the Baltic system was close to isolated, with too few lines to the rest of Europe. Talks on the first submarine cable, Estlink 1 between Estonia and Finland, began in 1999, but the link was only finished in 2006, after a harsh winter gave the project a push.
It soon became one of the most congested lines on the Nord Pool Elspot market, so a second cable, Estlink 2, followed in 2014.
The third connection to Scandinavia is NordBalt, a high voltage direct current cable between Lithuania and Sweden with a capacity of 700 MW, which began transmitting in 2016. Together these links let the Baltic states run a working Nordic-Baltic power market.
The only link to continental Europe at the time was LitPol, a 500 MW line between Lithuania and Poland that came into service at almost the same moment as NordBalt. It was central to the Baltic synchronisation plan, although experts argued that at least one more connection with Poland would be needed.
At the inauguration of NordBalt and LitPol, Miguel Arias Cañete, European Commissioner for Climate Action and Energy, said: “In a true ‘Energy Union’ there is no room for energy islands and electricity has to be able to flow freely across borders. Today we are taking a significant step forward in bringing more security of supply for electricity consumers in the region and in boosting competition on the electricity market.”
The price of leaving BRELL
Technical barriers often come with economic ones. Moving from BRELL to the European system has required heavy investment in power assets.
The investment in Estlink 1 was estimated at as much as 110 million euros. Private investors put up the money and recovered it through special tariffs, fees paid by those who used the interconnector.
Estlink 2 cost 320 million euros and was financed by the European Investment Bank. NordBalt, at 552 million euros, was built with money from the European Energy Programme for Recovery. LitPol, which received more than 550 million euros, appeared on the 2015 list of Projects of Common Interest.
Beyond what had already been spent, the countries would have to put more into their grids: stronger links with other European states, reinforced internal networks, new generation, and back-to-back converters on the borders with Russia and Belarus to handle asynchronous operation.
Kaliningrad and Poland
Synchronisation also carried a political risk. Kaliningrad, the smallest and a heavily militarised region of Russia, lies between Poland and Lithuania and was supplied from Russia through the Baltic grids. After desynchronisation it could be left running as an island. The region had enough generation to meet its own needs, and further investment in reserves was under way, but some experts feared the electricity question could turn into a political flashpoint.
Relations with Poland had their own difficulties. Warsaw had been reluctant to build a second LitPol line, possibly because of the cost (around 300 million euros on the Polish side), possible price competition from Lithuanian exports, environmental concerns and the reaction of local communities along the route.
Under the roadmap agreed in June 2018, the countries were to study an alternative to LitPol 2: a submarine HVDC cable between Poland and Lithuania. The European Commission undertook to let the transmission system operator concerned apply for EU funding.
The target held. ENTSO-E confirmed that the three Baltic systems were synchronised with continental Europe on 9 February 2025. The route it took is traced in the Baltic synchronisation guide, and the second Poland–Lithuania connection, Harmony Link, is now planned as an overland 220 kV AC line due by 2030.